I was first introduced to The Guild during a two-and-a-half month period of unemployment between grad school and the working world. I found myself with tons of free time, but an almost empty bank account. I needed free entertainment, and the webseries The Guild provided that easily. Right away, I was pulled into this funny little show about a group of gamers, and their trials both in and out of The Game (unofficially based on World of Warcraft). The comic version (also called The Guild) carries many of the strengths of the show, most which stem from the fact that it's very well balanced, and can deliver a lot in short periods. It's mostly a comedy, but it takes times for serious moments. The humor is edgy, and not afraid to flirt with the ridiculous, without being too over the top. The characters are both flawed and likable, and manage to be impressively well developed given their little screen time. There's a great amount of respect for gaming, and gamers, but Day is not afraid to poke fun at the community at the same time. Perhaps that most impressive thing about The Guild, in any format, is that it's clearly told from someone who's “been there,” making it feel incredibly authentic. If you're the type of person that likes to escape into fantasy worlds (whether that be through video games, books, or movies), chances are you'll be able to relate to Cyd.
The comic version of The Guild takes place before the events of the webseries, making it accessible for both new readers and existing fans. The artwork, done by Jim Rugg has two distinct styles. The panels that take place in the real world are defined by sharp edges and bold colors, while those which take place in The Game have a softer palate and rounder edges. I liked this a lot. The graphic novel version has bonus material, including cover art from the original issues of the comic books, short bonus comics, and early concept art. These elements are a nice little bonus, and lots of fun to look over.
Perhaps I'm a little biased, as I love the show so much, but I felt as if The Guild succeeds every way when it comes to what I look for in a graphic novel. It manages to tell an interesting, complete story with characters that feel true to life, and well done artwork. This is a nice selection to tie over fans until season five, as well as introduce new fans to the series.
Rating: five stars
Length: 96 pages
Source: Lewiston Public Library
Other books I've read by this author: this is my first
Next up I'll be reviewing River Marked by Patricia Briggs and Glimpses by Lynn Flewelling
xposted to temporaryworlds , bookish , and goodreads