starmetal_oak (starmetal_oak) wrote in bookish,

Review: The Tombs of Atuan by Ursula K. Le Guin

Title: The Tombs of Atuan
Author: Ursula K. Le Guin
Pages: 163
Genre: Fantasy
Rating: A
Challenge: Summer of Series - June and Support Your Local Library Reading Challenge 2010

From Amazon: When young Tenar is chosen as high priestess to the ancient and nameless Powers of the Earth, everything is taken away from her-home, family, possessions, even her name. She is now known only as Arha, the Eaten One, guardian of the labyrinthine Tombs of Atuan, shrouded in darkness. When a young wizard, Ged Sparrowhawk, comes to steal the Tombs' greatest hidden treasure, the Ring of Erreth-Akbe, Tenar's rightful duty is to protect the Tombs. But Ged also brings with him the light of magic and tales of a brighter world Tenar has never known. Will Tenar risk everything to escape the darkness that has become her domain?

I liked this story more than the one told in the first book in the series. I think this is mainly because I thought this story was more intimate than the first. I liked the first a lot and thought it had mainly good messages but I never really connected to Ged. In Tombs I connected to Tenar pretty quickly. Perhaps this is because her life doesn’t start off so well. She is forced into some pretty depressing circumstances and even pressured to commit horrendous tasks on behalf of being the priestess.

I liked seeing Tenar grow and navigate through her world which I think that she never truly accepted. In the end, Ged helps her to escape and for that I am happy for Tenar but I wish she would have done more on her own. She proved strong in the end but I also thought there was implications in the way that all the women on the site were subject to these dark powers and Ged, a man, came to reveal their ignorance and even rescue little Tenar. I would have liked to see a strong female heroine who wasn’t serving dark powers.

Something I felt was mysterious was the way the dark powers worked in the novel. Until Ged arrives in the story, there is no real display of dark magic or supernatural powers. We only know what Tenar has learned, that dark powers lived in the Tombs and Labyrinth and that such and such would happen were the rules broken. We never really got to see this. Neither does Tenar who experiences it as we do: by what the other priestesses were telling her. Even when Ged arrives it is through his testimony that we know what the dark powers are doing. I wonder what the real extent to their powers was. Surely there was some bad energy there, but was most of it superstition believed by the people? Kossil said something about this, about the powers being dead. Perhaps she was right and that the only power holding people there were their own fears. The only physical evidence is the collapsing of the tunnels in the end when Tenar and Ged escape (and I have to say that could have been Ged’s doing as much as anyone's). I wonder why Le Guin did not show us more in this regard if in fact the dark powers were significant.

In the end I enjoyed this story a lot but I did refrain from reading it from a feminist perspective at the time because I knew if I did I would feel differently about it. I don’t think children would notice these things and so it would be entertaining for them. I am giving this an A, the same as the first book, because I felt while this story was more interesting, the messages weren’t as strong as in A Wizard of Earthsea.

Currently Reading: Sunshine by Robin McKinley

xposted to blogspot

Tags: genre: fantasy, xxx author last name: a-h

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.